Best Better Than Sex mascara dupes have become a cult favorite among beauty enthusiasts. Fear not, because there are some amazing dupes out there that give you the same voluminous lashes without breaking the bank.
When it comes to mascara, I am always searching for the best better than sex mascara that can give me inky black lashes that are both long and thick. There is just something about this combination that instantly transforms my eyes and completes my makeup look. The quest for the ultimate mascara has led me to try numerous brands and formulas, but there are a select few that have truly captured my heart.
Bottom Line Up Front of best better than sex mascara dupes: 9 options to try.
The bottom line up front is that there are several alternative mascaras available that provide similar effects to the Better Than Sex Mascara. These options include L’Oreal Voluminous Lash Paradise, Maybelline Lash Sensational, Essence Lash Princess False Lash Effect, Benefit They’re Real, Tarte Maneater, Rimmel Scandal Eyes Retro Glam, Maybelline Full & Soft, L’Oreal Voluminous Original, and Lancome Monsieur Big. These mascaras offer intense volume, length, separation, and lift, catering to different preferences and budgets.
The 9 Best Better Than Sex Mascara Dupes I’ve Found
Here are some popular mascara dupes that I prefer the most.
L’Oreal Voluminous Lash Paradise
It is known for providing volume, length, and a similar effect to the high-end mascara. One of the standout features of the Lash Paradise mascara is its brush. Unlike traditional wands, this mascara comes with a soft bristle brush that picks up just the right amount of product to coat each lash without clumping or flaking.
Another impressive aspect of this mascara is its long-lasting formula. Once applied, it stays put all day without smudging or smearing. Whether you’re battling through a busy workday or dancing into the night at a party, your lashes will remain envy-inducing until you decide to take them off.
Its unique brush design and long-lasting formula make it an absolute must-have in any makeup collection. Say goodbye to lackluster lashes and hello to voluminous paradise!
Pros
- Cheaper than Better Than Sex.
- Available in drugstores.
- Good packaging.
- Has an hourglass shape.
- Has an identical–length, volume, and color.
- Available in other colors
Cons
- It can clump.
- It can flake.
Essence Lash Princess
When it comes to achieving fluttery and voluminous lashes, the Essence Lash Princess mascara reigns supreme. This cult-favorite product has garnered a dedicated following for its ability to transform even the sparsest of lashes into long and thick wonders.
What truly makes the Essence Lash Princess mascara stand out is its formula. The lightweight yet buildable formula ensures that each coat adds volume without clumping or weighing down your lashes. With just a couple of swipes, you can achieve an instant eye-opening look that will have people asking if you’re wearing falsies.
Its affordable price tag, exceptional performance, and user-friendly design make it a must-have in any makeup collection. Whether you’re going for a natural everyday look or full-on glam, this mascara will exceed your expectations and leave your lashes looking like royalty.
Pros
- Costs even less than Lash Paradise.
- Your lashes look so long and thick.
- Not clumpy.
Cons
- The tube seemed drier.
- Not easily available.
- Usually, mascaras smudge on me.
Maybelline Lash Sensational Sky High Mascara
Maybelline has once again exceeded expectations with their latest mascara innovation – the Lash Sensational Sky High Mascara. This beauty product promises sky-high, lengthened lashes.
The bristles of the Lash Sensational Sky-High Mascara’s wand are spaced out perfectly, allowing for an even distribution of product throughout your lashes. This not only prevents clumping but also ensures maximum separation and lift. From root to tip, each lash is coated with just the right amount of formula, giving them that weightless feel while still adding sensational volume.
Social media influencers have already been singing praises about this game-changing mascara.
Say no to false lashes or lash extensions because, with Maybelline’s Lash Sensational Sky-High Mascara, your natural lashes will take center stage in all their sky-high glory!
Pros
- Lots of lengths with substantial volume
- Deep, inky black color
- Another cute metallic pink tube
- Available in three shades of black and one brown
Cons
- It’s one of the more expensive drugstore options on the list at around $12.00, but it’s still less than half the cost of Better Than Sex. Plus, you may be able to find BOGO or BOGO 1/2-off coupons and save.
- Rarely smudges or flakes on me.
Tarte Maneater
The Tarte Maneater Collection has taken the beauty world by storm, and for good reason. With its fierce name and even fiercer colors, this collection is not for the faint of heart.
The Maneater Mascara is equally as impressive. Its unique wand design lifts and curls every lash while providing intense volume and length. Not only does it give your lashes an instant boost, but it also stays put all day without any flaking or smudging. The formula itself is also nourishing, containing ingredients like jojoba oil to keep your lashes healthy and strong.
Pros
- Such an inky black color! (But it also comes in brown for those who prefer a more natural look or have lighter hair.)
- Better formula than many options on this list, which may not be a pro for everyone.
- It’s water-resistant.
- It’s available in a mini size if you want to try it before you commit to a full tube.
Cons
- It can be hard to remove.
- Clumps worse than others on me (but it still looks good)
- The spiky brush isn’t like the fluffier, hourglass one and could hurt if you aren’t careful.
- Smudged a little on me.
- It only costs a few dollars less than Better Than Sex.
Benefit They’re Real
Unlike many other mascaras on the market, this one delivers on its promise of lengthening, volumizing, and curling lashes to perfection. The formula is not only smudge-proof but also holds up against humidity, making it perfect for long days or special occasions where you need your makeup to stay put.
With just a few coats of this magical mascara, you can achieve a wide-eyed look that lasts all day long.
Furthermore, Benefit They’re Real does much more than just enhance your natural lashes – it also creates a dramatic effect that mimics the look of false eyelashes without any hassle. The intense black color adds depth and intensity to your eyes, instantly making them appear bigger and more captivating. In summary, Benefit They’re Real is more than just another mascara – it’s an eyelash-transforming experience.
Pros
- It lasts a long time without smudging or flaking, but it’s still pretty easy to wash off.
- You can get a trial size before you commit to a whole full-size tube.
- It comes in black or brown. The black is intense.
- Gets every lash due to the brush design–spiky, with a domed tip.
- It’s truly an all-in-one mascara that does just about everything you could want one to do.
Cons
- It’s $27.00.
- The spiky brush can hurt if you’re not careful (I’ve poked my eye a couple of times, and it feels worse when it happens with this kind of brush!)
- It may separate your lashes a little too much for your liking. It makes this mascara better at lengthening than thickening, but the overall effect is still impressive.
Maybelline Full ‘n Soft
Not only does it deliver incredible volume and length to your lashes, but it also leaves them feeling soft and natural. Unlike some mascaras that can leave your lashes feeling crunchy or stiff, this formula keeps them flexible and touchable throughout the day.
Pros
- It makes lashes look soft and fluffy.
- It’s easy to remove.
- It’s cheap–under $10.00.
- You can find it at drugstores, grocery stores, big-box stores, Ulta, etc.
Cons
- The color isn’t as deep as Better Than Sex mascara.
- They don’t make it in many colors anymore (all I see is black).
- It’s not as dark as other options.
L’Oreal Voluminous Original Mascara
If there ever was a mascara that lives up to its name, it would undoubtedly be L’Oreal Voluminous Original Mascara. This cult-favorite product has garnered a loyal following for its ability to deliver va-va-voom lashes like no other. One swipe of this magic wand and your lashes are transformed into voluminous wonders that will turn heads wherever you go.
L’Oreal has managed to strike the perfect balance between lengthening and volumizing properties, giving you the best of both worlds. The uniquely designed brush coats every lash with an ultra-black pigment, adding depth and intensity to your eyes. Whether you have naturally sparse lashes or just want that extra oomph, this mascara delivers dramatic results without any clumping or smudging.
Pros
- You can get a straight or curved brush.
- It comes in different colors, like black, carbon black, black-brown, navy blue, cobalt blue, deep violet, and burgundy.
- It’s around $8.00.
Cons
- It may smudge.
- It seems to get thick and messy along the tube opening after a while.
Rimmel ScandalEyes Retro Glam Mascara
Rimmel ScandalEyes Retro Glam Mascara is a popular mascara that is known for its volumizing and lengthening effects. It has a unique hourglass-shaped brush that helps to lift and curl the lashes, giving them a retro, wide-eyed look. You’ll want to try this one if you love the intense lash look. It’s a wonderful budget pick you can find at Target, Walmart, and on Amazon.
Pros
- It’s one of the best budget picks at about $6.00.
- It provides an intense effect
- It thickens, lengthens, and darkens
Cons
- Only available in black.
- May flake.
- It could weigh lashes down in some cases.
Lancôme Monsieur Big Volumizing Mascara
Lancôme Monsieur Big Volumizing Mascara users often rave about its ability to add instant volume and length to their lashes. Many also appreciate the intense black color and the fact that it doesn’t clump or feel heavy on the lashes.
Overall, Lancôme Monsieur Big Volumizing Mascara is a popular choice for those looking to achieve bold and voluminous lashes with a single coat.
Pros
- A mini size is available to try.
- It’s designed for 24-hour wear.
- Delivers long, thick, extremely dark lashes.
- Dramatic effect
Cons
- The brush may be too big. It’s easy to poke your eye or make a mess of your lids.
- It’s as expensive as Better Than Sex mascara.
- It can be hard to remove.
- Only the black shade is available.
The selection criteria for finding the best better-than-sex mascara dupes include:
1. Formula: Look for a mascara with a similar formula to the Better Than Sex mascara, such as a thick and volumizing formula that can lengthen and curl the lashes.
2. Brush: The brush is also an important factor to consider. Look for a brush that has a similar shape and bristle density to the Better Than Sex mascara brush, which can help to separate and lift the lashes.
3. Longevity: A good mascara should last all day without smudging or flaking. Look for a mascara that is long-lasting and waterproof.
4. Price: The Better Than Sex mascara is a high-end product, so look for a dupe that is affordable and provides similar results.
Buying Guides
When searching for a dupe for the “Better Than Sex” mascara, there are a few factors to consider. These include the formula, brush shape, and overall performance. Here are some buying guides that can help you find the best dupe for this popular mascara:
- Beauty magazines and websites often publish articles and buying guides comparing different mascaras and their dupes. They provide detailed reviews and recommendations based on their testing and feedback from readers.
- Beauty bloggers and influencers: Many beauty bloggers and influencers share their opinions on various mascaras and their dupes. They often provide before-and-after photos, swatches, and detailed reviews. Look for bloggers who have similar preferences and lash types to yours for more accurate recommendations.
- Makeup forums and communities: Online communities like Reddit’s r/MakeupAddiction or Makeup Alley have dedicated threads and discussions about mascara dupes. Users share their experiences, recommendations, and even side-by-side comparisons of different mascaras and their dupes.
- YouTube reviews: Many beauty YouTubers create videos specifically comparing mascaras and their dupes. They often demonstrate the application process, discuss the formula and brush shape, and provide their honest opinions on how the dupe compares to the original “Better Than Sex” mascara.
Remember that everyone’s preferences and lash types are different, so what works for one person may not work for another. It’s always a good idea to read multiple sources and reviews to get a comprehensive understanding of different dupes before making a purchase.
Conclusion: Which One Should You Buy?
My top recommendation for a Better Than Sex mascara dupe is L’Oreal Voluminous Lash Paradise because it’s the closest match in every way.
If that one doesn’t work for you, my next choice would be the Maybelline Lash Sensational Sky-High mascara, which performs almost as well, but may add a bit more length and not as much volume. It also does an excellent job of separating and curling your lashes.
Finally, I’d say the Tarte Maneater option would be third place, especially if you don’t mind one that’s hard to remove. You’ll need a good eye makeup remover, but it may be worth it for the dramatic results.
Others on the list above get close to Better Than Sex’s results and provide length, intense color (if you want it), and volume. Some separate and curl better than others, though I didn’t experience particularly remarkable separation or curl when I used Better Than Sex, anyway. Those, to me, are additional benefits of some of the dupes on the list.
Question: What is the dupe for Better Than Sex Mascara?
Answer: L’Oreal Voluminous Lash Paradise is the best dupe for Better Than Sex mascara.
Question: What makes Better Than Sex Mascara so good?
Answer: Firstly, it is known for its volumizing effect, the mascara provides lengthening benefits, helping to create a more dramatic and eye-catching look.
Question: Is Better Than Love mascaras the same as Better Than Sex?
Answer: Yes, Better Than Love mascara is the same product as Better Than Sex mascara.
Question: Which mascara is best for length and volume?
Answer: Too Faced Better Than Sex Mascara is highly regarded for its ability to add both length and volume to the lashes, creating a dramatic and eye-catching look.
1 thought on “Best Better Than Sex Mascara Dupes: 9 Options to Try”